Monday, June 13, 2011
Passive & Off Grid. Yes, no, maybe?
Passive is really just a funky reference to using solar energy. It's as simple as that and no more. In fact solar is responsible for the winds, rivers and waterways too. So anything that uses hydro or wind or direct solar is just that: solar. And solar does not work so well when the sun does not shine. Or more directly, passive goes out the window when the sun does not shine: there is no passive heating, the solar panels are ineffective and there is no hot water. Simple. But when the sun does shine, it works a treat and that's probably 95% of the time. Human nature is such that when things are working fine, we take it all for granted - that's what we have been taught to expect. We're not grateful, it's just part of the service. And when things don't work just right, we're indignant, frustrated and even angry. Well if you plan to rely on passive energy and intend to be off grid, then your mood will definitely be defined by the weather and the moon phase may just make things worse. So be prepared and better still, change your habits and expectations well before you plan on providing your own services.
So just how big does it have to be for it to work? How many solar panels, how much water storage & how much habit change? Quite simply, if you don't want any habit change, then you're unlikely to have enough solar panels or water tanks. And even then, you'll be undone by the simplest of things. Take for example, our grey water tank that provides the water for all our toilets. Five hundred litres of water, which is enough for nearly 100 flushes. It gets refilled weekly and can last over a week but if one cistern has a slight leak, it won't last the night! 500 litres gone, just gone. The rain water storage of 30,000 litres which should be lasting us 6 months can be dusted in one month. This seems odd as we collect around two 500l tanks of grey water per week from all of our showers, basins and kitchen. Aaah, the vegetables! Take a hose to the vegetables and discover just how little water 30,000 litres really is. Add to that a dripping tap and your off grid dreams are down the plug hole. On the solar front, give yourself three days of continuous overcast weather and start considering the issues...the hot water's not so hot (in fact it's cold), the washing doesn't really dry that well and is backing up and the house is beginning to lose that comfortable temperature. Thankfully you still have electricity until of course the tumble drier is brought into play on the back of your geyser element. We don't have heaters (we have a very effective fireplace), but in a conventional house you'd need a whole new mortgage to install a solar array and battery bank large enough to deal with the combined assault of geyser elements, heaters and a tumble drier during an overcast spell.
Fortunately, one of the key requirements behind getting off grid was to be adaptable. This cannot be under-emphasised. We consistently fail to place sufficient value on the services our municipality provides us and in particular the endless supply of fresh water. Without this fairly basic service everything comes to an abrupt halt. Considering the value of this service, and now for the first time being able to appreciate its value, I'm surprised that every household does not have an emergency water reserve backed up by a borehole or rainwater harvesting. Absurdly we have insurance for all the expendable things in our lives but not this. One thing is for certain, in this house we can easily adapt to a very limited supply of water and I now know that it is in the adapting where the difficulty lies.
So you want to get off grid then? Easy. Go and camp in a remote spot for six months. One where there is no running water, sanitation, hair dryers, hot water, clean clothes, hair dryers and straighteners or fresh vegetables. Get your habits and expectations adapted first and then move into your off grid home. You'll then be grateful for all the luxuries that present themselves and will easily cope on those days when the sun does not shine. You'll also understand the value of water and that it's far more important than having light. You'll also understand the value of having a plan B since an off grid plan A is not as reliable as being plugged into a power station or a supermarket.
Thursday, April 7, 2011
How to Boil a Frog
I was having my mandatory morning coffee the other day and got chatting to a solar supplier and it was the usual dialogue about the solar business and our choices. It's an interesting dynamic in that we would expect the major electricity increases to spur people to invest in energy saving devices - but it remains a trickle although the awareness is growing. Also there are issues with solar that don't really help, the main one being that it does not really provide an uninterrupted service - especially when the sun does not shine (like at night and when it's overcast). However, when we had the euphemistically named 'load shedding' there was a scramble for alternatives. It was then I realised that we're all frogs (in a manner of speaking).
Apparently (and I have not tried it) if you put a frog in cold water and bring the water to boil, the frog eventually overheats and dies. But if you drop a frog into hot water, it has a tendency to move fairly rapidly to escape the heat. The frog's behaviour is governed by the rate of change of his environment. When it changes rapidly and significantly, it responds appropriately but if the change is gradual (although equally significantly in the long term), the frog persists with trying to adapt to the change and eventually doesn't and then dies.
So despite today the fuel price and electricity prices have pushed new highs and are expected to do so well into the future, we continue to shrug off the heat and will try a bit harder.
It seems the Japanese have been suffering a long and drawn out deflationary period where every effort by their government to 'kick start' their economy has achieved nothing. It has resulted in a growing pile of debt for Japan but it also seems to be eroding domestic savings. If you take a look at a graph of Japanese savings over the past 20 years, it has been in gradual decline for some time and has almost reached the point where there are no longer any savings to mention. I can only speculate that this is an example of the cold water frog syndrome, where individuals dip into their savings on the basis that everything will to return to 'normal' tomorrow. As time progresses, the savings are reduced to the extent that any change they could have made is now very difficult or not possible at all.
Equally here in SA, had the government raised our electricity costs by 930% in one step instead of doing so over a ten year period (25% compounded over 10 years), we would have been hot water frogs instead of cold water ones. Had the same or something similar been done to the price of fuel, the double whammy would have had everyone focusing on and investing in a new lifestyle - which probably would have included low energy habits, smaller houses and very small cars called bicycles. Of course there would have been a huge adjustment, but that adjustment tsunami is coming regardless of the current or future pain and because it's happening so slowly, we ignore it. Unfortunately if we follow Japan's savings path, in ten years time very few people will have any savings at all and making the switch to a low energy lifestyle will become almost impossible. For everybody else, access to credit will also probably have evaporated so it amounts to the same net result.
For 20,000 years there was minuscule growth (and progress) and for all intents and purposes it was a flat line. In the last 100 years we've had exponential everything including appetites. For some reason we are convinced that the last 100 years is the norm and the previous 20,000 were the aberration. What if we are wrong? Can we as cold water frogs learn to behave differently? Perhaps at some point we'll recognise that we're in a pot on a burning stove and that warm fuzzy feeling needs some deeper consideration.
Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Off Grid Two Step
I'm beginning to realise that being offgrid electrically is like driving a Prius. You keep looking at your consumption and trying to improve on your last 'record'. I find myself telling my kids when they're watching television that it's being powered by sunlight. Awesome. I'm also now switching off lights in empty rooms and the TV at the wall to remove it from standby. The computer's power function, which was completely ignored up until now has been configured to switch off the monitor after 10 minutes, the hard disks after 20 minutes and to euthanize it after half an hour of inactivity. This may be a sign that I’m a little obsessive but whatever it is, being off the electrical grid was step two.
Step one was to get off the water grid. We finally installed three 10,000 litre water tanks after quite a bit of deliberation. Not that there was any deliberation about getting off the water grid, but there was quite a bit of research on how to do it. I went to several companies trying to work out how best to store water and every time I was told that stored water goes "off". How on earth does H2O go off? Apparently it's not the H2O, it's all the organics that are suspended in the water that go off. Then I thought that I'd distil it all using some solar panels and even did the sums to work out how much energy is needed to boil and evaporate 500 litres of water per day. This process would simply remove all of the 'bits' in the water and I'd have perfectly clean and healthy water to drink - until I learned that distilled water is not fit for human consumption! Apparently it has no dissolved salts and if you drink it, it leeches all the salts out of your body. It's not an isotonic solution! It makes sense if you follow the logic so that option was also ruled out. Then I was told that rainwater is not that good for you anyway. How's that possible, we've been drinking it for thousands of years without any problems?!! Well it's the acid rain argument, but it had a new twist. It's full of pesticides. All those inorganic farmers spray their crops with poison and some of this remains suspended in the air and the rain washes it out. There really was no solution to this dilemma and it was becoming as confusing as cell phone contracts. There seemed to be an infinite number of reasons why every type of ‘natural’ water was not good for me and then of course why I needed to pass it through a whole lot of gadgets that cost fortunes of money to make it 'fitter' for human consumption.
I thought I would sterilise the water using a UV light. I'd already been informed about the myriad of bacteria that could possibly harm us and of course it's their cousins that make the water go off in the first place. So sterilising seemed the sensible thing to do and UV seemed the least intensive option. Finally I went in search of a UV supplier to be told by the first water treatment company I visited that a UV light does not work. It works a little, but not enough. Then I went to another water company and they said it works perfectly. Apparently they had installations where people were running river water through one of their units and it passed all the potable water tests. Obviously I would also need a filtration system which is a series of filters down to as little as one micron, which is very small. It was very confusing. All of this work to stop my water going 'off'. I even explored a reverse osmosis system. Now that's seriously high tech. It's also seriously energy intensive and expensive. Energy is an issue to me and we don't have an abundance of it being 'offgrid'. I now fully understand the meaning of ‘finite’ so that option died a rapid death. Then of course there's the Hydrogen Peroxide option, which is a popular industry solution to a lot of bacterial problems. It would also entitle us to free hair bleach with every shampoo. It doesn't repair split ends though, so we dispensed with that option. In the end, I decided to speak to someone in the know.
John, who works for me, lives in kaBokweni. He has a trickle of electricity and no water at all. He collected his water every morning from a filthy nearby stream and that's what they used to wash with. He'd take home five litres of water from time to time for drinking. However, he does have a solid house with a tin roof and we decided to install a rainwater harvesting system for him around 18 months ago. The tank was full throughout the rainy season and it almost carried him over the winter. In fact he was a few days away from making it through to the first rains the following summer. Since there was no-one else that harvests and stores rainwater in this neighbourhood, I asked him how 'off' his water was. Well it wasn't at all. He said it was crystal clear and tasted good throughout the year (despite the leaves that had fallen in his tank) and he confirmed that none of his family of five was suffering from any mysterious illness either. They all still had ten fingers and toes. His biggest problem was that all his neighbours wanted access to his water also.
Well that sealed it. I decided not to treat the water at all except for removing the visible bits from it. To do this, I put in a tiny pump that circulates the water through the smallest possible sand filter. All the harvested rainwater goes through this filter and every day for half an hour, it circulates the water in the storage tanks through the filter also. Obviously not all the water is filtered every day but it keeps it 'moving'. I don't know if this is too little or too much treatment, but in the end 'moving the water' is ultimately only a psychological cure to some psychological ailment that now exists my head insofar as storing water goes. If I've still got ten fingers and toes next year, then I'll know things are probably OK. If not, I'll have to make some changes.
Step three is getting off the food grid. Now that's a completely different ball game. All I know is that everything else will be easy in comparison so I'm not shredding my credit card just yet.
Tuesday, February 1, 2011
What would I Do Differently?
What would I do differently? I get asked this all the time and it is probably asked to establish whether there's an easier way to becoming more sustainable than the road I've taken. Not that I'm yet living sustainably but the gap is much smaller than it used to be. Also there is a lot to be learned and even more to be unlearned. So it's a journey and it's in progress.
The real question is 'what does sustainable mean'? Having gone down this road, there are many shades of sustainability often referred to as 'going green'. The most cynical type is really the 'greenwashing' of businesses or behaviours - the "PR Green". BP is a great example of this changing from British Petroleum to Beyond Petroleum with a nice green sun as its logo followed closely by being responsible for the largest oil spill in US history. Some things just are not sustainable and the way we’re currently exploiting the planet (and each other) falls nicely into that category.
Being sustainable today calls for urgent and meaningful changes in our expectations and behaviour. On a global level, technology will not save us. Technological progressions just increase our ability to outcompete our environment and are the antithesis of sustainability. When I began this process, I believed that globally we were capable of stepping back from the brink; that we could reason and rationalise and by doing so would come to the simple conclusion that we urgently need to make changes to our way of doing business and our capitalistic value system. However, now I’m not so sure. I’m beginning to believe that we have more in common with the reindeer of St. Matthew Island than I ever thought was possible.
On an individual level, building a 'green' house or 'passive house' is not the answer either. Such a house may be a step in the right direction. It'll help to reduce one's energy footprint by eliminating the need for vast amounts of heating, cooling, water, electricity etc. But while there is an expectation for all the luxuries of modern life, that position will never be truly sustainable. It is also almost impossible to change one's own lifestyle when all your peers do not see the same need for change, which is a euphemism for sacrifice. In changing, one occupies an isolated position. Generally, and it's a generalisation of course, we're conditioned to take the path of least resistance with maximum comforts (and making difficult changes towards sustainability is not on this path). In fact I'll go so far as to speculate that most people will be willing to exhaust all of their savings trying to maintain their current lifestyle and only when they've exhausted all options (like borrowing more), will they accept change as inevitable. Ironically at that point, they'll be least able to make the change. Unfortunately I believe this to be true of businesses, schools and society at large.
“The Last Hours of Ancient Sunlight” was a random pick of many books on the subject. “Plan C” by Pat Murphy was for me a better read and most recently there’s the “Post Carbon Reader” which gives an in-depth analysis on the subject. With a little bit of effort, it is easy to substantiate the message in these books. The message is quite simple: our economies (and hence lifestyles) are powered by fossil fuels and we are dangerously close to passing tipping points that will impose dramatic change upon us. It’s important to note that we will never run out of fossil fuels, we’ll just run out of our ability to pay for them (or the things they make). So the energy threat will never manifest itself as a shortage of energy but will always manifest itself as a financial one.
In fact, there’s a large body of evidence that believes when energy costs exceed 5.5% of US GDP, it puts the US into a recession as illustrated in the graph. Whatever you believe, there is a direct link between the performance of an economy and the cost of it's energy inputs. So if you're going through a financial squeeze, then you’re probably on the road to Sustainability 101.
There are three major fossil fuel pillars in our daily lives: food, transport and household use. All of these are within our ability to control.
The average calorie of US food takes 10 calories of fossil fuel to produce and deliver to the consumer. In view of this, there is little wonder that in 2008 there were food riots in over 30 countries as the oil price spiralled up towards record highs. This was corrected by the Great Recession, which is now supposedly behind us. Today, again as the oil price goes through $100/barrel and food prices are hitting new record highs, food price triggered demonstrations are spreading throughout the Middle East – that region where globally we can least afford volatility as it has a direct effect on the price of oil. This could turn out to be a perfect example of a positive feedback loop. But what’s important to understand is that commercial food uses huge amounts of energy and the price of food is inextricably linked to the price of energy (fossil fuels). And in today’s society where very few of us grow our own food, we’ll just have to reach deeper into our pockets to feed our families.
We all know the cost of our personal transport. But is it possible to imagine a world without our ability to travel at will? What will you sacrifice to maintain your transport freedom - 200 channels of mindless television, mandatory holidays or designer labels? In our public transport starved country where private car ownership is entrenched, try climbing on a bus or into a taxi while your peers cruise in their airconditioned SUV’s and appreciate why this is a lonely road to take out of choice.
In South Africa our electricity costs are doubling every two and half years. So in two and a half years they’ll double and then two and a half years later double again. It's exponential growth at a rate well beyond likely increases in income. All of this energy goes into perfectly manageable lifestyle choices. So if you’re sitting with your salary cheque in your pocket and it fails to cover all the escalating costs in your life, you’re going to have to make some changes. And when you make this decision, it’s Sustainability 102.
So then, what have I learned and what would I do differently? I now know it’s possible to dramatically reduce the energy and water used in a house and I certainly don’t think it’s necessary to build a new house from scratch to do this. So the first thing I would do is not build a new house. If anything, I'd sell my existing house and move into a much smaller one and use the spare cash to make the following changes:
- Replace every light in the house with low energy lights and preferably LED lights where feasible. This includes all outside security lights.
- Replace the electric hob and stove with a complete gas unit
- Retrofit a hot water solar panel to the EXISTING geyser and only use the element in the geyser as a last resort. Insulate all hot water pipes where quite a bit of heat escapes.
- Heavily insulate the ceiling and ensure the roof is then well ventilated so that it does not continue to behave like an oven.
- Plant deciduous trees on all east and west facing walls to protect them from direct sun in the summer. Remove all evergreen trees that block the sun from heating the house in the winter.
- Learn to live without the many heating elements that are currently taken for granted: electric heaters, tumble drier (the sun works perfectly well), dishwashers & washing machines that heat the water (rather supply them hot water from the solar powered geyser) etc.
- It’s prohibitively expensive to get off the electrical grid completely, especially if you don’t plan to make any lifestyle changes. If I were doing it again, I’d put in a much smaller electrical backup system and tie this into a deliberate lifestyle change. When you have no electricity, it’s a fairly compelling reason to change. So switching off unnecessary lights or the TV when no one is watching really will become a habit.
- Transportation is where the change is hardest. Freedom of movement is well entrenched in our behaviours and society. You’re expected to drop you kids here, there and everywhere based on the functions at school or of their friends. The prevailing argument against our children walking or using bicycles is safety. There’s equally no appetite to create cycle or pedestrian lanes to change the status quo. It’s emotional blackmail and it works. So on this item, it’s really each to his own but the location of your house is very important.
- Food is an interesting issue. It’s supposed to be possible to feed your family out of a vegetable garden the size of a front door. Ours is much bigger and we’re frankly very poor at it. Being organic in 'bug city' where there’s an orgy of growth of everything makes this fairly difficult. It’s much easier to grow veggies in the colder months. Nevertheless yields arrive in batches far greater than can be normally consumed. I’m now of the opinion that food independence can only be reasonably achieved by working within a small community where between the group, a reasonable diversity of products can be produced, preserved and shared. An improvement on this is Community Supported Agriculture where a community supports and shares the risk of a larger scale farming operation. It's as close as you can come to growing your own food without doing the growing. It also deals with the meat issue; urban dwellers prefer to believe that meat comes in vacuum packed parcels and this is one way to perpetuate the illusion. However when faced with killing your pet chicken or pet pig for the pot, vegetarianism becomes overwhelmingly appealing.
- Finally, by installing low flow showers, not having any baths (jacuzzi or a swimming pool), we use very little potable water. We don’t have a meter, but we probably treat less than 150l of grey water per day for a family of four. Water independence at this rate of consumption is fairly easy to achieve considering the rains we’ve been getting lately and to achieve this you would also have to stop watering your roses.
Sunday, November 21, 2010
Lessons Learnt
Passive Heating
The very first lesson in the middle of winter was how warm the living room was. The sunlight flooded into the room as the patio roof had still not been installed and the floor sucked up this warmth. At night this radiated out as though the underfloor heating was on full bore.
Biodigester
The biodigester does work in so far as it produces gas. It's also very combustible but there is a significant psychological barrier to using this as a replacement for existing cooking gas supplies. So at the moment I burn off some gas during a demonstration from time to time - but this really is a issue of boys with their toys. However, the intention is to compress the gas into a cylinder and then to burn it off for non-cooking purposes such as hot water heating or to use it in the hot house when that's finally up and running.
Grey Water Treatment
A greywater treatment plant is not a greywater treatment plant until you can build up sufficient microbial activity to process all the soaps and stuff in the water. It is, after all, a living filter and requires life to function. So after four months of promoting life and cleansing, the greywater treatment bed is now fully functional. The toilet cisterns are being filled 100% with recycled water and I've told no one in the house. The moment they hear this news, it'll be a matter of time before a psychosomatic smell appears in the house again.
Hot Water Solar
This is a great success. However not so when it's overcast. In fact, it would be safer to say that they do not work in overcast conditions - at all. But when the sun shines, they cook. Below is a plot of our electricity consumption for the geyser and lights only over a period of 4 days.
Roof Vegetation
However even they were struggling just before the rains came this summer. They were seriously dehydrated so we intervened with some water. They have since made a great recovery and now that the rains have returned, the roof is again rich in green. But what's growing there is anyone's guess. I have a very apathetic view of this; whatever flourishes will and whatever won't will die. It's a bit like any ecosystem in the world.The Garden
The worm farm is a great success. However the chickens have discovered them and the worms are now having to take some evasive action. The 'worm tea' is flowing abundantly. Not that it's all the worms doing. When it rains, the worm tea is literally leached out of the wormery and now I have a reservoir of the stuff.
The vegetables are growing well. Everything grows well in this area but I really don't have a clue about growing vegetables. Some things flourish then fail while others stumbled at first and then blossom. I do not have any idea what to expect except that when it begins to yield food, it comes in a massive tidal wave. I've even started buying books that instruct you on how to preserve food but I can't say they're a riveting read.
I raided the beehive the other day and ended up with around 2 litres of honey. I left the bees more honey than I took but at least it was a start. I've since invested in some more hives and I relocated a hive from a nearby estate into one of them. So I'm waiting on the second to become occupied and I hope this takes place soon. By next year, I should be off the honey grid.
I suppose the one lesson in all of this is that you don't just wake up one day and become food secure because that's your intention. It's a process of learning something completely new and the independence is something that takes months if not years to achieve.
The Chickens
They're a pain in the butt. They go on strike when they're put in the chicken tractor but cause chaos when they're not. The vegetables are taking a hammering and I have to ring fence each plant to save it from destruction - especially the broccoli and cauliflower. In the meantime they breed like rabbits but the chick mortality is high - not that we've seen a dead baby. I think the snakes are having a field day. The house has boycotted eating fertilised eggs as they have this 'white spot' which inevitably means the snakes are getting to eat more offspring. Not that I've seen a snake either. But we don't want to lock them up and when we forget to put them away at night, Rodney the rooster gives us the 4h30 alarm call outside our window. Rodney has nearly been turned to stew on several occasions now. This is a real love hate relationship and I'm often seen pursuing them around the garden like Mr Plod.
Saturday, June 5, 2010
In - the end
We moved in on the 27th of May and that was a milestone of note. The house was not quite ready, but we had to move out of our rented accommodation by the end of May and so we moved.
Of course the rain did not let up until almost the last day. We started wet (the first rains) and ended wet and now that we're in, the clouds have vanished bar a couple of overcast days.
These of course arrived as we were beginning to lay the paving and concrete panels around the house. I'm fairly keen to avoid a damp problem so we've paved and cast a 1.4m wide hard surface area all the way around the house.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Fuzzy Warm
Currently we are busy with installing all the pipework, geysers, pumps and controllers in the 'control room'. The pumps are beautiful little things that can be set to different operating powers: 30, 60 or 90W. This is quite handy when you have different flow requirements and they are the same pumps that were supplied with the solar hot water panels.
Just to boost the heating in winter, I have ordered a slow combustion fireplace with a boiler attached. This will be connected into the system and the beauty of this is that we will be able to distribute the heat from the fireplace throughout the house. It supplements the solar heating, which is what we will be using to heat the water that will heat the house.
To cool the house, all we do is pump cool water through the pipe network. This should cool the floor down to around 15 degrees C which should make everything feel quite comfortable. The cool water is provided by a geothermal loop that has been buried outside - all 600m of it. Again this is free energy except for the circulating pump which uses next to no power even at full output. Nevertheless, considering the design of the house I expect that the heating and cooling needs will be minimal even at the worst of times.
So the only question that now remains is how well does all of this work? And that answer needs a bit of time and experience. But it will work.